Newfoundland’s Big Choice: Canada or Independence?

World wars and flamboyant orators changed the British colony's destiny in the twentieth century.
Podcast hosted by Kate Jaimet — Posted April 1, 2024

In 1948, the people in the British colony of Newfoundland faced a choice. They could become an independent country within the British Commonwealth. Or, they could vote to join Canada in Confederation. In this episode of our Stories Behind the History podcast, we travel to St. John’s, Newfoundland, to interview former Premier Clyde Wells, artist Kathleen Knowling, writer Bernice Morgan, and former MP Richard Cashin about their memories of the Confederation debate, and to ask them if they think Newfoundlanders made the right choice when they joined Canada. 

Part 1: Life in a British Colony

Read the transcript

Part 2: The Confederation Debate

Read the transcript

Part 3: Life after Confederation

Read the transcript

You could win a free book!

Sign up for any of our newsletters and be eligible to win one of many book prizes available.

Sign up now!

More from Stories Behind the History

Behind Barbed Wire: A German POW in Canada

Exploring the memoirs of a captured Nazi sailor.

NATO vs Russia: 75-year standoff

Founded in 1949, the NATO military alliance grew out of the ashes of the Second World War.

Mi'kmaw Myths & Canadian Lore

What uncanny creatures lurk in the depths of the Canadian wilderness? Gather ’round the campfire for some spine-tingling stories of the supernatural.

Vancouver: Hippie City, Heroin City

From Vancouver’s nineteenth-century opium dens, to the 1970s hashish trade through Montreal’s French Connection, drug use and abuse has created subcultures with their own personalities and rituals. 

Canada in the Korean War

A stress point in current global tensions, the border on the 38th Parallel is a seventy-year-old legacy of the Korean War. Seventy years after the 1953 armistice, Canadian War Museum historian Andrew Burtch and Chief of the Defence Staff General Wayne Eyre discuss Canada’s involvement on the Korean Peninsula, from wartime to the present day.

How Prince Edward Island Joined Canada

More than 200 years ago, the British monarchy promised the Mi'kmaw people the right to hunt and fish on the island forever. But what happened to those treaties when PEI joined Canada in 1873?

Quest for the Northwest Passage

Best-selling historical author Ken McGoogan discusses the bold and gruesome search for the Northwest Passage with Kate Jaimet, senior editor of Canada's History magazine.

The Canada-India Connection

Many of the same British aristocrats wielded power in both India and Canada. A podcast with international relations scholar Madhuparna Gupta, historical non-fiction author Stephen Bown and senior editor Kate Jaimet.Winner of the 2023 Canadian Ethnic Media Award for Podcast Feature.

Audio credits:

Ode to Newfoundland: licensed under Creative Commons from wikimedia  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Newfoundland_and_Labrador.ogg

Snare drums: Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution non-commercial license from zagi2 on Freesound.org. https://freesound.org/people/zagi2/sounds/673466/

All archival audio from the National Convention: Public domain. Provided by The Rooms Provincial Archives Division.

Themes associated with this article

Related to Politics & Law

A War on Two Fronts

In the Great War, the Canadian state found itself fighting two fronts. And the historical irony is striking: while thousands of working-class men and women were marched off to Europe, ostensibly to defend the rights and freedoms of democracy against tyranny, such highly prized ideals were routinely—and often severely—violated at home.

Article

Perceptions of the Red River Resistance

In this podcast, Philippe Mailhot explains how understandings of the Red River Resistance are changing.

Podcast

More Democracy... or Less?

Political scientist Royce Koop responds to “The Ballots Question,” discussing the process of choosing a party leader, whether the system we have now is more or less democratic, and how other countries choose the leaders of their parties.

Podcast

Slow Road to Tolerance

It’s hard to say when attitudes in Canada began shifting towards a more tolerant, multicultural society. Perhaps it began with the Holocaust.

Article